• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • RSS
  • Archives
  • Subscribe
The Nut Graph

The Nut Graph

Making Sense of Politics & Pop Culture

  • Projects
    • MP Watch
    • Found in Conversation
  • Current Issues
    • 6 Words
    • Commentary
    • Features
    • Found in Quotation
    • News
  • Columns
  • Interviews
    • Exclusives
    • Found in Malaysia
  • Multimedia
    • Audio
    • Pictures
    • Videos
  • Corrections
  • Letters to the Editor
  • Vault
    • Found in Translation

Tok Guru vs Tok Guru

By Shanon Shah

June 15, 2009

“If you are not a fisher[folk], you cannot talk about fishing. It’s the same with SIS (Sisters in Islam), if you do not have knowledge about Islam, you cannot talk about Islam.”

PAS president Datuk Seri Abdul Hadi Awang, on why he is adamant that the Muslim women’s non-governmental organisation should still be silenced despite protests even from PAS’s Pakatan Rakyat (PR) partners. On 7 June 2009, the 55th PAS muktamar resolved that SIS should be investigated by the National Fatwa Council, and if its work was found to be against Islam, to have it banned and its members rehabilitated. (Source: Hadi: SIS know nothing about Islam, The Malaysian Insider, 11 June 2009)

“I have met SIS leaders before and have no problems meeting them again … We should have more discussions and not simply ban the group.”

PAS spiritual adviser Datuk Nik Abdul Aziz Nik Mat, explicitly disagreeing with Hadi on the very same day. Nik Aziz said that PAS should not ostracise SIS but make attempts to enlighten the group via dialogue. (Source: Enlighten group members instead, says Nik Aziz, New Straits Times, 11 June 2009)

“I will continue to express my displeasure in the open and if they want me to keep quiet, I want to know why … Even during Prophet Muhammad’s time, this was never done as every question has an answer.”

PAS spiritual leader Datuk Nik Abdul Aziz Nik Mat, stressing that in Islam there is no such thing as telling someone to shut up. Nik Aziz, however, was referring specifically to PAS election director Mustafa Ali’s call for members not to question the party’s talks with Umno on a potential unity government. (Source: Nik Aziz: I will not shut up, The Star, 11 June 2009)

“They are ignorant about Islam. We have tried to engage them by sending (PAS Kota Raja Member of Parliament) Dr (Siti) Mariah (Mahmud) to one of their events but they talk not from their knowledge.”

Hadi again, on PAS’s attempts at “engaging” with SIS. (Source: Hadi: SIS know nothing about Islam, The Malaysian Insider, 11 June 2009)

“I don’t agree with banning them because I believe everybody needs to be able to speak their minds … People think they are wrong, but I think their thoughts are rarely heard in Malaysia, and people tend to misunderstand them … So if they invite me to their functions, I will go, because I don’t have any problems with them.”

Mariah, defending SIS on the day the muktamar’s resolution on SIS was passed. Mariah’s Muslimat peer, Dr Lo’ Lo’ Mohamad Ghazali also defended SIS, saying that calling for them to be banned was not an “inclusive step”. So far, Mariah and Lo’ Lo’ seem to form part of a very small minority of PAS leaders who have opposed any calls to ban or silence SIS. (Source: PAS wants Sisters in Islam investigated, The Nut Graph, 7 June 2009) Favicon


Disclosure: Shanon Shah is an associate member of Sisters in Islam.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)

Related Stories

Filed Under: Found in Quotation Tagged With: censorship, freedom of speech, Hadi Awang, logical fallacy, mariah mahmud, muslim, nik aziz, pas, Shanon Shah, SIS, Sisters in Islam, weak analogy

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Hafidz Baharom says

    June 15, 2009 at 9:36 am

    So now with Dr Siti Mariah, Dr Lo’ Lo’ and even Nik Aziz mentioning that they have no problem with SIS and that PAS should talk with them, one must wonder just what is going on with PAS’s president?

    He’s all over the place.

    He wants to talk with Umno when Khalid Abdul Samad and Nik Aziz, not to mention the entire women’s wing of PAS, says that he shouldn’t.

    Personally, I can’t help wonder if the SIS agenda is a personal one. What did Yati Kaprawi do to piss off Hadi?

    But whatever it is, bravo to Yati.

  2. megabigBLUR says

    June 16, 2009 at 10:58 am

    “If you are not a fisher[folk], you cannot talk about fishing. It’s the same with SIS (Sisters in Islam), if you do not have knowledge about Islam, you cannot talk about Islam.”

    By the same reasoning, doesn’t that mean if you’re not a woman, you should shut up about women’s issues and leave SIS alone?

Primary Sidebar

Search

Twitter

My Tweets

Recent Comments

  • Wave33 on The Nut Graph stops publication
  • Adam on The Nut Graph stops publication
  • PSTan on The Nut Graph stops publication
  • PSTan on The Nut Graph stops publication
  • Andre Lai on The Nut Graph stops publication

Recent News

  • The Nut Graph stops publication
  • Nasihat tentang sepupu yang mengganggu perasaan
  • Uncommon Sense with Wong Chin Huat: The Sunni-Shia split and the answer to Muslim unity
  • Why Malaysia needs the national unity bills
  • Challenging government in the digital age: Lessons from Kidex
  • Najib’s failure
  • Babi, anjing, pondan: Jijik orang Islam Malaysia
  • Kidex and the law – What the government’s not telling you
  • Beyond Dyana Sofya
  • Uncommon Sense with Wong Chin Huat: Does Malaysia need hate speech laws?

Tags

Abdullah Ahmad Badawi Anwar Ibrahim Barisan Nasional BN Bukit Selambau by-election dap Deborah Loh Ding Jo-Ann Election Commission elections Found in Malaysia Found in Quotation Gan Pei Ling government high court Hishammuddin Hussein ISA islam Jacqueline Ann Surin Khairy Jamaluddin KW Mak Lim Guan Eng Malaysia MCA Menteri Besar MP Watch Muhyiddin Yassin muslim Najib Razak Pakatan Rakyat Parliament Parti Keadilan Rakyat pas Penang Perak PKR police politics prime minister Selangor Shanon Shah Umno Wong Chin Huat Zedeck Siew

Footer

  • About The Nut Graph
  • Who Are We?
  • Our Contributors
  • Past Contributors
  • Guest Contributors
  • Editorial Policy
  • Comments & Columns
  • Copyright Policy
  • Web Accessibility Policy
  • Privacy Policy
The Nut Graph

© 2023 The Nut Graph