Categorised | Columns

Testing the MBPJ

LOCAL government elections seems to be a hot topic in Malaysia’s current political landscape. The belief is that a local council would be more accountable to the taxpaying public if elections are held.

The Election Commission, however, will not conduct local government elections because it violates the Local Government Act. So while we are stuck with it for the time being, the public can still use this piece of legislation to keep their respective local councils accountable and transparent.

Meetings public

Section 23 of the Local Government Act states that all local council meetings are open to the public. But it adds a clause that exempts committee meetings from being open to the public, unless the committee decides otherwise. Little wonder, then, that the local council automatically applies this clause to all committee meetings.

This clause does not cover the local council’s full board meeting held at the end of each month. This is why the press and the public are allowed to enter the boardroom to observe the proceedings of the full board meeting. They are, however, only allowed to speak if the meeting’s chairperson — usually the mayor or council president — gives permission.

Those who wish to observe the monthly full board meetings of the Petaling Jaya City Council (MBPJ) can obtain the meeting dates and times on the council’s website. The schedule is uploaded every month on the main page in one of the bullet points.

Ratepayers who would like to attend the full board meeting must wear formal attire. The absolute minimum is an office shirt with tie and pants for men, and a blouse with skirt that covers the knees for the ladies. MBPJ officers are instructed to escort a person out of the room if they are not properly attired.

Meeting minutes

Section 27(3) states that the minutes of all local authority proceedings shall be kept at the local authority’s office and shall be available to any councillor, ratepayer or government officer from within the local authority’s area. The law also stipulates that any of these individuals are allowed to make a copy of any part of the minutes without fee.

However, the Act also says that the minutes of any committee proceedings shall not be open to inspection by a ratepayer unless the local authority otherwise directs.

(Meeting pic by Sigurd Decroos /

(Meeting pic by Sigurd Decroos /

It should come as no surprise that the meeting minutes of all committees are, by default, unavailable to the public. However, the exemption doesn’t apply to the minutes of the local council’s full board meeting, and should, technically, be available to the public upon request.

This part of the law was not applied by the MBPJ back when I was still a reporter (and also a Petaling Jaya ratepayer). Then, access to the full board meeting minutes was denied to me and other ratepayers, even though we argued about it. With the Pakatan Rakyat now at the helm of Selangor, will the MBPJ be making things easier for ratepayers?

Testing required

Kampung Tunku assemblyperson Lau Weng San has motioned for the full board meeting minutes to be publicly available and even uploaded on the MBPJ website. This matter was raised in February, and  I was made to understand unofficially that the public can request to view the minutes but not make copies.

I’m not aware of any forms that the public would have to fill in order to gain access to the information. So I have to assume that the request can be made via mail, with an attachment of the assessment bill as proof that the person requesting for the minutes is a ratepayer.

Would someone like to test if they can gain access to the full board meeting minutes and report back to me on their success or failure? In the event of a failure, do record the reasons given and/or obstacles that were faced. I can’t test this myself since I’m a councillor, and the minutes are automatically available to me.

Khir Toyo (Pic by JohnLeeMK / Wiki commons)


There is also the matter of the Official Secrets Act that is used to keep the local council minutes secret. The former Selangor menteri besar, Datuk Seri Khir Toyo from Umno, empowered MBPJ deputy secretary Ahmat Mohayen Said to classify MBPJ documents as secret. But with the power to classify comes the power to declassify.

Would someone also want to volunteer writing in to the local council to request for the declassification of a committee meeting’s minutes?

Before he became a councillor, KW Mak was part of the resident-initiated effort with Edward Lee, who is now Bukit Gasing assemblyperson, to gain access to the MBPJ’s accounts. The accounts were made available for download via the MBPJ website when the Pakatan Rakyat came into power.

Read previous Ampersand columns

The Nut Graph needs your support

Post to Twitter Post to Google Buzz Post to Delicious Post to Digg Post to Facebook Post to StumbleUpon

Tags: , , , , ,

4 Responses to “Testing the MBPJ”

  1. Mikazuki says:

    I would gladly attend any MBPJ full board meeting to observe, but the thing that I need to complain is (I bet you have enough complaints to deal with – just bear with me) the MBPJ website is not updated enough. As of now, no sign of the April 2010 meeting schedule being put up on MBPJ official website.

    How will the PJ residents know the schedule if MBPJ won’t even bother to update their website? In this day and age with technology getting better and better. I have to say the MBPJ website is a sad sight to see.

  2. KW Mak says:

    @ Mikazuki

    The MBPJ website is notoriously slow at uploading data. Normally, everything gets uploaded by the 15th (give or take a few days). In any case, the full board meeting for MBPJ will be held at 10:30am this 28 April.

  3. Hwa Shi-Hsia says:

    I thought the Official Secrets Act was supposed to be for protecting matters of national security, not preventing local residents from knowing about decisions that may significantly affect their quality of life. That’s just unjust.

  4. KW Mak says:

    @ Hwa Shi-Hsia

    The OSA has been used at the local council for as long as I can remember.

    As for why Pakatan Rakyat doesn’t just remove the OSA from use at the local council level, you will have to ask the Selangor Exco that question. Without directive from the top instructing otherwise, everything remains status quo.

    Perhaps, if I were to take a guess, it is because there isn’t sufficient public pressure on this particular issue and the urgency of implementing this policy isn’t all that urgent in the eyes of the present Selangor government. After all, the number of people expressing their desire to write officially to MBPJ to demand for the meeting minutes as I have suggested is, thus far, zero.

Most Read (Past 3 Months)

Most Comments (Past 3 Months)

  • None found




  • The Nut Graph


Switch to our mobile site