Categorised | News

Amir Muhammad’s latest film restricted

Malaysian Gods poster (pic courtesy of Da Huang Pictures)

PETALING JAYA, 30 Jan 2009: Amir Muhammad‘s latest film, Malaysian Gods, has been barred from wide release by the censors.

The National Film Censorship Board has decided that the roughly 60-minute movie cannot be shown on TV or in cinemas. The board gave no reasons for its decision despite an appeal by Da Huang Pictures which produced the film.

“I think they don’t want the hassle of ‘banning it’, but they also don’t want the hassle of being harassed for ‘allowing it’, so they are taking the middle ground,” the award-winning filmmaker told The Nut Graph via e-mail from Rotterdam, where he is attending the city’s 2009 international film festival.

This is not the first time Amir has run into trouble with the authorities for his films about Malaysian history or historical events.

Notably, two of his films The Last Communist (2006) and Village People Radio Show (2007) were banned. Both works deal with the Malayan Communist Party. Because they were banned, both received a fair share of publicity.

The censorship board said The Last Communist had to be banned in the public’s interest, while Village People was a “distortion of historical fact”.

The Film Censorship Act 2002 states that the reasons for censorship could include obscenity or material that may be “contrary to public interest”.

Malaysian Gods is an “experimental video, documentary and fiction” that backdrops the 1998 Reformasi movement. It conducts interviews in Tamil, with English sub-titles, with Tamil-speaking Malaysians who work or patronise areas in Kuala Lumpur which were the site of anti-government Reformasi demonstrations.

The film was submitted to the censorship board in late October 2008. The board made its decision in three weeks.

Not re-submitting

Although Amir has made some changes to the film since submitting it to the censors, he is not going to re-submit it for approval.

Amir Muhammad (pic courtesy of Danny Lim)

“I don’t see why I should pay a fee just to update them, and get the same result,” he said.

Describing the censors’ decision as “quite strange”, Amir said he would instead arrange for screenings in other venues. “We plan to screen it in many local campuses,” he added.

The film was first screened on 20 Sept 2008, at the 10th anniversary of the Reformasi march, at Golden Screen Cinemas, 1-Utama for one day only while waiting for the censors to respond to the producer’s appeal.

The film, originally titled Do You Remember the 20th Day of September, was shot in June 2008.

The idea for Malaysian Gods came to Amir when he was stuck in a traffic jam on a rainy day near Dataran Merdeka.

“The whole place seemed to come alive, in my head, as a massive demonstration site. It was a false memory, since I was not actually there on 20 September 1998. So [the film] was my attempt to ‘place’ myself there,” Amir said.

He added that he conducted all the interviews in Tamil because he had always wanted to make a Tamil movie. “So, this was my chance.”

Post to Twitter Post to Google Buzz Post to Delicious Post to Digg Post to Facebook Post to StumbleUpon

Tags: , , , , , ,

9 Responses to “Amir Muhammad’s latest film restricted”

  1. Nurulhuda says:

    Commendable…. we need more young people like him. People who are brave and dare to be different. That is what makes him stand out from the rest. Send to Singapore… you surely will get the support.

  2. Eric says:

    Responsible policing the BN way: “The board gave no reasons for its decision”. The little Napoleons ban as and when they like and they do not have to justify for it. It is called “being brave to expose their opinion”.

    I hope this will change once BN becomes federal opposition.

  3. Ruzaini says:

    Tidak dibenarkan membikin filem yang memberi sejarah hitam buat negara. Hanya dibenarkan filem yang memberi sejarah manis buat negara. Seperti contoh filem Bukit Kepong, Leftenan Adnan Saidin, malah jika mahu biografi Datuk Lee Chong Wei.

  4. izwan says:

    Nak tengookkk! Tapi kenapa dalam bahasa Tamil erk?

  5. mem says:

    It’s a lousy movie anyway. Congrats!

  6. Nurulhuda says:

    “Nak tengookkk! Tapi kenapa dalam bahasa Tamil erk?”

    Kenapa tak boleh. Kamu boleh tengok filem Hindi dengan subtitle Inggeris dan BM. Nyanyi Hindi pun pandai walaupun tak tahu makna lagu… kenapa bahasa Tamil tak boleh…. tentu ada subtitle dalam Bahasa Melayukan [sorry okay… tak boleh kata bahasa Malaysia…di Singapura kita panggil bahasa Melayu].

  7. Ying says:

    Screening it at galleries and campuses is a great idea. You don’t have to pay thousands to have it screened at TGV, GSC and the like. You don’t need surround sound right?

  8. chin y says:

    I really liked when I saw it at KLPAC. It was a full house. Would buy the DVD for sure. Or download it 😉

  9. Nurulhuda says:

    mem Posted: “It’s a lousy movie anyway. Congrats!”

    Sour graphs you are!

Most Read (Past 3 Months)

Most Comments (Past 3 Months)

  • None found




  • The Nut Graph


Switch to our mobile site