• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • RSS
  • Archives
  • Subscribe
The Nut Graph

The Nut Graph

Making Sense of Politics & Pop Culture

  • Projects
    • MP Watch
    • Found in Conversation
  • Current Issues
    • 6 Words
    • Commentary
    • Features
    • Found in Quotation
    • News
  • Columns
  • Interviews
    • Exclusives
    • Found in Malaysia
  • Multimedia
    • Audio
    • Pictures
    • Videos
  • Corrections
  • Letters to the Editor
  • Vault
    • Found in Translation

Plan to reacquire Kamunting hits snag

By Khairil Anhar

November 3, 2008

KUALA LUMPUR, 3 Nov 2008: The Perak state government’s plan to reacquire the land where the Kamunting detention centre is situated from the federal government may experience hiccups, said law experts.

Universiti Teknologi Mara’s professor of law Dr Shad Saleem Faruqi told The Nut Graph that reacquiring Kamunting is not feasible.

Shad said that Articles 83 to 86 of the Federal Constitution grant the federal government the authority to refuse a state’s request to acquire land under its power.

“It is not feasible for the Perak government to acquire the Kamunting land, since the Articles in the constitution clearly provide the edge to the federal government,” he said.

Shad also said the Articles clearly declare that it is up to the federal government to release the land to the state government.

The idea to reacquire the land from the federal government was mooted by Penang Chief Minister Lim Guan Eng on 24 Sept as part of his “road map” to abolishing the Internal Security Act (ISA).

On 5 Oct, Perak state executive councillor A Sivanesan said that the Pakatan Rakyat-led Perak government would look into the legal avenues to see how the state could reclaim the land alienated to the federal government to build the camp.

The state, he said, would look into the Land Acquisition Act to see how it could order the Barisan Nasional (BN) government to move the camp out.

In a report on 8 Oct, Home Minister Datuk Seri Syed Hamid Albar scoffed at the suggestion to relocate Kamunting, saying that properties under federal jurisdiction cannot be easily taken back by the state.

Lawyer Derek Fernandez, an expert in local government and town planning law, said while there is no provision in the Act that prohibits the state from acquiring land from the federal government, it depends on the nature of the agreement between them. Attempts to find out the status of the Kamunting land from Perak Legal Advisor Datuk Ahmad Kamal Md Shahid were futile.

Fernandez however agreed that Articles 83 to 86 of the Federal Constitution may hamper the Perak government’s effort.

“The state government cannot acquire the land if the grant of the land is given to the federal government for a public purpose which is in the national interest,” he said.

But this point is open for interpretation.

“The question is whether the existence of Kamunting [camp] is in the national interest,” Fernandez said.

 

 

Filed Under: News Tagged With: isa detention camp, kamunting, Lim Guan Eng, perak state, reacquiring land

Primary Sidebar

Search

Recent Comments

  • Wave33 on The Nut Graph stops publication
  • Adam on The Nut Graph stops publication
  • PSTan on The Nut Graph stops publication
  • PSTan on The Nut Graph stops publication
  • Andre Lai on The Nut Graph stops publication

Recent News

  • The Nut Graph stops publication
  • Nasihat tentang sepupu yang mengganggu perasaan
  • Uncommon Sense with Wong Chin Huat: The Sunni-Shia split and the answer to Muslim unity
  • Why Malaysia needs the national unity bills
  • Challenging government in the digital age: Lessons from Kidex
  • Najib’s failure
  • Babi, anjing, pondan: Jijik orang Islam Malaysia
  • Kidex and the law – What the government’s not telling you
  • Beyond Dyana Sofya
  • Uncommon Sense with Wong Chin Huat: Does Malaysia need hate speech laws?

Tags

Abdullah Ahmad Badawi Anwar Ibrahim Barisan Nasional BN Bukit Selambau by-election dap Deborah Loh Ding Jo-Ann Election Commission elections Found in Malaysia Found in Quotation Gan Pei Ling government high court Hishammuddin Hussein ISA islam Jacqueline Ann Surin Khairy Jamaluddin KW Mak Lim Guan Eng Malaysia MCA Menteri Besar MP Watch Muhyiddin Yassin muslim Najib Razak Pakatan Rakyat Parliament Parti Keadilan Rakyat pas Penang Perak PKR police politics prime minister Selangor Shanon Shah Umno Wong Chin Huat Zedeck Siew

Footer

  • About The Nut Graph
  • Who Are We?
  • Our Contributors
  • Past Contributors
  • Guest Contributors
  • Editorial Policy
  • Comments & Columns
  • Copyright Policy
  • Web Accessibility Policy
  • Privacy Policy
The Nut Graph

© 2025 The Nut Graph