• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • RSS
  • Archives
  • Subscribe
The Nut Graph

The Nut Graph

Making Sense of Politics & Pop Culture

  • Projects
    • MP Watch
    • Found in Conversation
  • Current Issues
    • 6 Words
    • Commentary
    • Features
    • Found in Quotation
    • News
  • Columns
  • Interviews
    • Exclusives
    • Found in Malaysia
  • Multimedia
    • Audio
    • Pictures
    • Videos
  • Corrections
  • Letters to the Editor
  • Vault
    • Found in Translation

“Tian Chua keeps seat if EC stays mum”

By Ding Jo-Ann

June 23, 2010

Tian Chua
Tian Chua

PETALING JAYA, 23 June 2010: Batu Member of Parliament Chua Tian Chang will keep his seat if the Election Commission (EC) refuses to declare it vacant, said constitutional lawyer Tommy Thomas.

This is despite Thomas’s view that Chua was disqualified as an MP when the High Court fined him RM2,000 for biting a police officer.

“It’s so clear that he’s disqualified. It’s a matter of plain English. I can’t see how to argue otherwise,” Thomas told The Nut Graph in a phone interview. “But if everyone including the EC keeps quiet, then nothing will happen.”

Thomas agreed that the EC’s inaction would render the Federal Constitution impotent since Article 48(1)(e) clearly states that a person is disqualified from being an MP if convicted and sentenced to a fine of not less than RM2,000.

“The EC can be brought to court for not upholding the constitution but only by someone with locus standi,” said Thomas. “This would definitely include Tian Chua and the government of Malaysia, who were parties in the criminal prosecution.”

When asked whether a Batu constituent could sue the EC for not calling a by-election, Thomas said this was “possible”. “Malaysia is more restrictive on who has locus standi, so it depends. But in other more mature democracies, a Batu voter would probably have locus to sue the EC. They would have an interest to ensure their MP doesn’t break the law.”

Parliament cannot interfere

Tommy Thomas
Tommy Thomas

Thomas stressed that Chua’s position as an MP was out of Parliament’s hands, disagreeing with views that a parliamentary vote could settle the issue.

“Tian Chua’s disqualification falls under Article 48(1)(e) of the constitution, which is related to court convictions,” Thomas said. He explained that according to Article 53(2), however, Parliament has no say over an MP’s position arising from a court conviction.

“In all other instances of disqualification such as being of unsound mind, Parliament decides. But when it comes to court convictions and sentences, only the court decides. Parliament has no business interfering.”

Thomas said this was to make clear the separation of powers between Parliament and the courts and to avoid any conflict between the two branches of government.

No by-election

Zaid Ibrahim

Thomas speculated that Batu constituents wouldn’t be facing a by-election anytime soon.

“Batu has always been an opposition seat, it was [Gerakan co-founder Tan Sri Dr] Tan Chee Khoon’s seat for many years. The political reality is Umno doesn’t want to lose another by-election, particularly by a big margin,” said Thomas.

Thomas also postulated that a Batu by-election could pave the way for Datuk Zaid Ibrahim to be fielded as a candidate and win in the relatively urban seat.

Thomas said the legal issue could be cleared up if Chua filed an appeal.

Chua’s lawyer said on 22 June that Chua would be applying for leave next week to appeal against the court decision that he was guilty of biting a police officer.

[related-posts]

The Nut Graph needs your support

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)

Related Stories

Filed Under: News Tagged With: 2000, Article 48(1), Batu, Constitution, Election Commission, Federal Constitution, mp, Parliament, parliamentary caucus on democracy, Tan Chee Khoon, Tian Chua, Tommy Thomas, Zaid Ibrahim

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Sean says

    July 2, 2010 at 11:19 am

    If TC keeps his seat this way, wouldn’t he be effectively muzzled in Parliament? An MP’s normal privilege in being able to say what he likes without fear of defamation suits wouldn’t be worth much if a victim were able to point out “but the law says you’re not actually an MP, doesn’t it?”. Isn’t that an obvious flaw in what is otherwise an abysmal plan?

Primary Sidebar

Search

Twitter

My Tweets

Recent Comments

  • Wave33 on The Nut Graph stops publication
  • Adam on The Nut Graph stops publication
  • PSTan on The Nut Graph stops publication
  • PSTan on The Nut Graph stops publication
  • Andre Lai on The Nut Graph stops publication

Recent News

  • The Nut Graph stops publication
  • Nasihat tentang sepupu yang mengganggu perasaan
  • Uncommon Sense with Wong Chin Huat: The Sunni-Shia split and the answer to Muslim unity
  • Why Malaysia needs the national unity bills
  • Challenging government in the digital age: Lessons from Kidex
  • Najib’s failure
  • Babi, anjing, pondan: Jijik orang Islam Malaysia
  • Kidex and the law – What the government’s not telling you
  • Beyond Dyana Sofya
  • Uncommon Sense with Wong Chin Huat: Does Malaysia need hate speech laws?

Tags

Abdullah Ahmad Badawi Anwar Ibrahim Barisan Nasional BN Bukit Selambau by-election dap Deborah Loh Ding Jo-Ann Election Commission elections Found in Malaysia Found in Quotation Gan Pei Ling government high court Hishammuddin Hussein ISA islam Jacqueline Ann Surin Khairy Jamaluddin KW Mak Lim Guan Eng Malaysia MCA Menteri Besar MP Watch Muhyiddin Yassin muslim Najib Razak Pakatan Rakyat Parliament Parti Keadilan Rakyat pas Penang Perak PKR police politics prime minister Selangor Shanon Shah Umno Wong Chin Huat Zedeck Siew

Footer

  • About The Nut Graph
  • Who Are We?
  • Our Contributors
  • Past Contributors
  • Guest Contributors
  • Editorial Policy
  • Comments & Columns
  • Copyright Policy
  • Web Accessibility Policy
  • Privacy Policy
The Nut Graph

© 2023 The Nut Graph