Categorised | News

DCM issue: PR falling into BN-style politics

THE prolonged vacancy of the Penang Deputy Chief Minister (DCM) 1 post shows the pitfalls of Barisan Nasional (BN)-style politics and governance that the Pakatan Rakyat (PR) government there appears to have fallen into, a political analyst said.

The DAP-led state government, helmed by Chief Minister Lim Guan Eng, should not have to depend on PR adviser Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim to decide on what is essentially a public office issue, Khoo Kay Peng said.

Khoo is of the view that it is Lim’s prerogative as head of Penang to appoint another assemblyperson on merit to be the new DCM 1 or even an acting DCM to replace Mohammad Fairus Khairuddin.

“But his hands are tied because the post has been promised to Parti Keadilan Rakyat (PKR) under Pakatan Rakyat’s power-sharing agreement. It is not that different from the race-based BN political culture, and this is disappointing,” Khoo told The Nut Graph.

Lim said in a statement in Penang today that although he was disappointed with the delayed announcement, he accepted that Anwar had to face “political pressures” in making a decision.

Lim said even though he had the prerogative as chief minister to appoint a replacement, he believed in consulting and waiting for Anwar to decide after resolving internal PKR matters.

Delay in announcement

Lim was originally to have revealed Fairus’s replacement on 12 April, but delayed the announcement till today at Anwar’s request, only to be asked to postpone it again.

Fairus, the Penanti assemblyperson, was DCM 1 until his resignation, which was effective 8 April. He tendered his resignation letter on 21 March, following allegations of links to illegal quarrying activities. He has since been investigated by the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC), and may face charges soon.

Fairus was said to be one of Anwar’s protégés and was thus given the DCM 1 post following the March general election last year. There are two other Malay Malaysian PKR assemblypersons that would logically be considered to fill the vacancy — state executive councillor Abdul Malik Abdul Kassim, who holds the Batu Maung seat, and Sungai Bakap assemblyperson Maktar Shapee.

It appears that Anwar’s choice lies between choosing either Abdul Malik or Maktar, or allowing Fairus to vacate the Penanti seat in favour of a by-election in Penanti with the candidate becoming DCM 1 if PR wins.

When Fairus’s resignation took effect, Anwar had said he would remain the Penanti assemblyperson until the next general election. But that looks set to change, especially if the MACC presses charges and he is convicted.

Consider issues separately

Khoo says the Penanti by-election and selection of a new DCM 1 should be considered separately for the sake of the state’s administration.

“Pakatan needs to move quickly into governing especially at a time of economic crisis like this. This involves a public position, and it is irresponsible leadership to say that the post will be left vacant until Anwar solves his party’s internal problems,” says Khoo.

Fairus had also held important exco portfolios such as entrepreneur and cooperative development, information and community relations. However, he has been deemed a non-performer and Anwar was once said to have ticked him off for not visiting his constituency.

PKR and state leaders, however, say there is no urgency in finding Fairus’s replacement as the state continues to be run well.

“I don’t think the delay in filing the appointment will affect the administration of Penang. The state is being administered well, Anwar is fully aware of the situation, and PKR does not want to be given ultimatums on when to decide,” said PKR deputy president Dr Syed Husin Ali said when contacted.

Penang DCM 2 Prof Dr P Ramasamy, from the DAP, said Anwar’s consultation process with his own party should be allowed to take place.

“Anwar and Guan Eng also consult one another on this. We are Pakatan Rakyat, we do things on the basis of consultation. Yes, we need to fill up this post but if this happened in the BN, there would also be delays as political parties need to be consulted. We are not worried about the state, because Anwar will announce [his decision] soon,” Ramasamy said.

Of the 40 seats in the Penang state assembly, DAP holds 19 seats, PKR nine, and PAS one. The remaining 11 are held by Umno.

Post to Twitter Post to Google Buzz Post to Delicious Post to Digg Post to Facebook Post to StumbleUpon

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

7 Responses to “DCM issue: PR falling into BN-style politics”

  1. tilianker says:

    Come to think of it…only two persons to choose from and there’s so much delay. It is easier to criticise…just like DAP in the past, belittling MCA for wearing the ceremonial songkok. Placed in MCA’s shoes, they did the same.

    So, let’s not be taken in by what they preached. In the end, it boils down to the reality that Malaysians by and large are trapped under the race cap.

  2. looes74 says:


    Again there are 10 exco members in the team. I am more in favour of hiring more advisers instead. I don’t think it’s a pressing issue. Perhaps, Umno might use this issue of stirring the Penangite Malay [Malaysians] that they don’t have a Malay [Malaysian] DCM1.

    I don’t think it’s wrong to suggest that Anwar should settle their internal political matters. It sounds like BN style but hey, when you don’t have majorities to stand on your own, one has to rely on consultation.

    People, we need to have political wisdom. Anyway, I am extremely sure that Umno would fully exploit the issue.So will DAP.

  3. Andrew I says:

    “It is not that different from the race-based BN political culture.”

    Excuse me, but did I miss something here? Who said anything about race? It seems like a straightforward power-sharing arrangement to me and Guan Eng is holding up his end of the bargain.

    Unless we all evolve to look the same, we are still differentiable by race.

    Let’s not get carried away by being overly politically correct.

  4. Said says:

    I have a feeling that it has to do with the decision to be taken by MACC. My suspicion is based on the fact that unlike other cases involving opposition figures, MACC, in this particular case, is taking its time in deciding if they want to prosecute.

    BN wants MACC to hold the decision (to prosecute or not to prosecute) until Anwar names the replacement. Once the new DCM is announced, MACC will declare that there is no case against Fairus. BN will then annouce that Fairus is crossing over to their camp as a clean person.

    Knowing this, I guess Anwar is trying to buy time and see if he can push MACC into making the decision before he announces the new DCM. I don’t think Anwar is that stupid to keep postponing the announcement for no reason. His credibility is at stake, he cannot be seen as a fickle-minded person. But he needs to be assured that Fairus is not being lured into the other camp.

  5. Hantu Laut says:

    The Pakatan gang has shown they are no better than the BN.They are full of bravado and live under false pretences.They will truly show their true colour when they take over the federal government.

  6. Penangite says:

    The appointment of DCM 1 for Penang is not a pressing issue.

    Anyway, the appointment has to be made in the spirit of PR leadership camaraderie and understanding based on consensus and consultations.

    MCA has no comparison as they have not garnished the support of the community which they are supposed to represent.

    BN is playing the political game using the offices of the MACC in Penang and so likewise, Guan Eng and Anwar are trying to be on top of them.

    The essence is the governance of Penang and if they can still provide a good government responsive to the needs of the rakyat, and at the same time is competent, transparent and endeavours to be corruption-free, the people of Penang are more than satisfied.

    The BN governments of the past has no comparison.

  7. tilianker says:

    Sea Ghost! I can’t help but agree with you.
    The word Pakatan spells and smells illicit.
    Pakatan’s colour is red, green or blue..
    Are we being democratic or stupid..
    In time we will wake up as fools
    PAS is more powerful and strategic.
    DAP like MCA will be a mere tool
    Supporting Anwar will be so tragic!
    Going against Umno is so cool..
    However there’s no magic in politics.

Most Read (Past 3 Months)

Most Comments (Past 3 Months)

  • None found




  • The Nut Graph


Switch to our mobile site