Categorised | Columns

A councillor’s life

MBPJ logoI HAVE been retained as a councillor in the Petaling Jaya City Council (MBPJ) by the-powers-that-be and have agreed to continue serving for a third year. The following are my personal thoughts about being a councillor for the past two years.

Challenging challenges

Petaling Jaya residents are often quick to organise themselves to stand up for their rights against large corporations. These can be anything from the management of a condominium to a developer of a proposed project next door.

The effectiveness of such protests usually hinge on the residents’ unity and the sacrifice the group’s leaders are willing to make, as the challenges that await these protesting residents are many.

In many instances, I have witnessed resident groups starting the fight with bravado, only to see their numbers dwindle as the defamation lawsuits fly their way.

The tools at a large corporation’s disposal aren’t limited to legal threats: I have also witnessed intimidation by gangsters.

Subtler but no less effective is the reported attempts of bribing resident leaders to keep them quiet. This leaves the protesting few that remain easily branded as troublemakers. It also makes trusting your neighbour all the more difficult.

Difficult task

Helping residents avoid being caught in such sticky situations is where I come in, as the local council is a regulating body for many of the issues that residents protest against.

To be an effective intermediary, I must have all the relevant information at my fingertips. Sadly, working in an environment where transparency and accountability isn’t a standard, getting access to all the information I need is sometimes difficult, even through official channels.

Indeed, my experience with certain government departments includes:

  • Lengthy response time – about a month or more – to my inquiries.
  • No reply forthcoming despite repeated reminders.
  • A reply with only a portion of the questions answered.
  • A reply with answers to questions I did not ask.

Thankfully, I am not without resources, and contacts made during my many years as a journalist have been able to help me piece together the information I need. With limited resources and having multiple threads of issues to follow, information gathering takes time, and people with no patience often accuse me of being useless or corrupt.

Those who understand the difficulties I face as a councillor are appreciative and thankful, and I draw inspiration from their gratitude to continue doing what I do.

Fear and faith

Sticking my nose into the issues residents face also subjects me to the same threats and bribe offers the resident groups encounter. To assure the public that I will not sway, I often state my stand in letters to the residents and in my column on The Nut Graph.

Envelope full of money

Councillors are susceptible to bribe offers

In making these public statements, I am often asked: “Aren’t you afraid?” The question stems from the fact that I do not hide behind the veil of anonymity when I voice my opinion, and any offended party can easily single me out for persecution.

I do not have unlimited resources, or fantastical fighting skills if confronted by gangsters. But I do have a sound mind to work out solutions for the problems I encounter, and faith in the Almighty for problems that are completely beyond my ability to manage.

Another often-asked question is: “How do you make ends meet with the RM1,800 to RM2,000 per month the local council pays you?” Well, I do complain about it, but that is just human nature.

It isn’t difficult to survive with the money I earn, but it is difficult to save. Again, having faith matters, as there are times when I do need extra money for emergencies. And somehow, God provides.

MBPJ councillor KW Mak would like to someday return – via legal means – to an income bracket that allows him to pay taxes, as the benefit of having free parking in Petaling Jaya as a councillor is really overrated.

The Nut Graph needs your support

Post to Twitter Post to Google Buzz Post to Delicious Post to Digg Post to Facebook Post to StumbleUpon

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

7 Responses to “A councillor’s life”

  1. Shawn Tan says:

    Wow! You get *free* parking?!! Sweet! 😀

  2. Reza says:

    Dear Mak,

    I am glad that you have been retained as a councillor for MBPJ. I am sure you will continue to do an excellent job. Although, I must say that I am a bit puzzled as to why the usually corrupt municipal councils would retain honest and diligent councillors.

    I have an aunt who was councillor for the Subang Jaya municipal council until recently. Unfortunately, she was not as lucky as you as she was just dropped from the council. She was very outspoken and pro-active against errant developers. Whenever I saw her, she would usually relate to me her latest battles against those who did things that were not in the best interest of SJ residents. I guess she must have really ruffled some feathers. One of her supporters had even lambasted Seputeh MP Teresa Kok for not retaining her. And some are still undertaking efforts to have her reinstated. I hope they are successful, because we need councillors like you and my aunt in the municipal councils.

  3. Sean says:

    “And somehow, God provides.”
    I know that – it’s a Selangor Adun’s asset declaration!

    I like your articles. They bridge a yawning gulf between what one might hope happens at a local council and the creeping suspicion of what actually does happen. I find it odd that there’s only one councillor voice such as yours in the whole of Malaysia. Am I looking in the wrong places?

    How is the issue tracker coming along? I think there’ll be no movement at all on tardy offices until you have the hard facts to back up your observation – all the more reason for a prototype. “I told you” is going to look very old in four (three development + one use) years’ time. Are you going to be there in four years’ time?

    • KW Mak says:

      @ Sean

      The three years I mentioned to develop the software isn’t so much the time frame for developing the software but the process of identifying the requirements and securing the funding to do the project.

      I’m not an all-powerful politician that can make things happen without justifying the need for it with facts and data.


  4. Mikazuki says:

    A sound mind is way better than any “fantastical fighting skills” but sure won’t hurt if you know some martial arts move, Hai yah!! haha

    Glad to know there’s still people with integrity in the local council. I guess there’s still hope for the people in PJ after all.

    Your article have been an eye-opener for mere people like me who actually just starting to care about what happen in our own neighborhood.

    Keep up the good work!

  5. Patrick says:

    You know, your column sounds like a mishmash between an uphill battle, and tragic comedy.

    It must really be challenging for a member of the public to get answers, especially when councillors get so much trouble through official channels already.

    • siew eng says:

      This is how a freedom of information legislation can help empower citizenry. Even councillors, ya?

Most Read (Past 3 Months)

Most Comments (Past 3 Months)

  • None found




  • The Nut Graph


Switch to our mobile site